XII
Detailed Valuation Scenarios
================================================================================ VALUATION SCENARIOS - DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW (DCF) ANALYSIS ================================================================================ 📊 DYNAMIC GROWTH RATE CALCULATION FOR MELI ━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ Historical Data Inputs: • Revenue CAGR 13yr: 38.7% • EPS CAGR 13yr: 24.8% • Quality boost: ROIC 16.6% (>15%) • 📊 Using EPS CAGR only: 24.8% • 📊 Good ROIC (16.6%) → Factors: Bear 50%, Base 75%, Bull 100% • 📊 DATA-DRIVEN BASE: 24.8% × 75% = 18.6% • 🔻 Bear: 24.8% × 50% = 9.0% • 🔺 Bull: 24.8% × 100% = 12.0% Weighted Historical Growth: 31.7% Industry: Specialty Retail (Consumer Cyclical) Industry Growth Modifier: +0.0% Quality Adjustments: +1.0% Growth Rates (10-year projection): 🔻 Bear Case: 7.5% (conservative, recession-resistant) ⚖️ Base Case: 12.0% (sustainable, achievable) 🔺 Bull Case: 12.0% (optimistic, strong execution) Growth Rate Bounds: • Industry floor: 2.0% • Industry ceiling: 12.0% Stock: MELI Current Price: $1988.26 Shares Outstanding: 0.05B (50,697,375 shares) Base Year FCF (FY 2024): $7.1B (from financial statements) -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- BEAR CASE (Probability: 25%) Conservative: Below-trend growth, elevated risk premium, modest recession impact ASSUMPTIONS: • FCF Growth Rate (Years 1-10): 7.5% • Discount Rate (WACC): 12.0% • Terminal Growth Rate: 2.0% 10-YEAR FCF PROJECTION: Year FCF ($M) PV Factor PV of FCF ($M) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 $7,587,350,000 0.8929 $6,774,419,643 2 $8,156,401,250 0.7972 $6,502,233,139 3 $8,768,131,344 0.7118 $6,240,982,701 4 $9,425,741,195 0.6355 $5,990,228,931 5 $10,132,671,784 0.5674 $5,749,550,090 6 $10,892,622,168 0.5066 $5,518,541,381 7 $11,709,568,831 0.4523 $5,296,814,272 8 $12,587,786,493 0.4039 $5,083,995,842 9 $13,531,870,480 0.3606 $4,879,728,152 10 $14,546,760,766 0.3220 $4,683,667,646 ------------------------------------------------------------ Total PV of 10-Year FCF: $56,720,161,798 TERMINAL VALUE: • Year 11 FCF: $14,837,695,981 • Terminal Value: $148,376,959,811 • PV of Terminal Value: $47,773,409,986 VALUATION SUMMARY: • Enterprise Value: $104.5B • Shares Outstanding: 0.05B • Intrinsic Value per Share: $2061.12 • Current Price: $1988.26 • Upside/Downside: +3.7% • Margin of Safety: 3.5% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- BASE CASE (Probability: 50%) Balanced: Sustainable growth trajectory, market-appropriate discount rate, realistic perpetuity assumptions ASSUMPTIONS: • FCF Growth Rate (Years 1-10): 12.0% • Discount Rate (WACC): 10.0% • Terminal Growth Rate: 2.5% 10-YEAR FCF PROJECTION: Year FCF ($M) PV Factor PV of FCF ($M) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 $7,904,960,000 0.9091 $7,186,327,273 2 $8,853,555,200 0.8264 $7,316,987,769 3 $9,915,981,824 0.7513 $7,450,023,910 4 $11,105,899,643 0.6830 $7,585,478,890 5 $12,438,607,600 0.6209 $7,723,396,688 6 $13,931,240,512 0.5645 $7,863,822,082 7 $15,602,989,373 0.5132 $8,006,800,666 8 $17,475,348,098 0.4665 $8,152,378,860 9 $19,572,389,870 0.4241 $8,300,603,930 10 $21,921,076,654 0.3855 $8,451,524,001 ------------------------------------------------------------ Total PV of 10-Year FCF: $78,037,344,068 TERMINAL VALUE: • Year 11 FCF: $22,469,103,571 • Terminal Value: $299,588,047,611 • PV of Terminal Value: $115,504,161,350 VALUATION SUMMARY: • Enterprise Value: $193.5B • Shares Outstanding: 0.05B • Intrinsic Value per Share: $3817.58 • Current Price: $1988.26 • Upside/Downside: +92.0% • Margin of Safety: 47.9% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- BULL CASE (Probability: 25%) Optimistic: Strong execution, market share gains, operating leverage, sustained competitive advantages ASSUMPTIONS: • FCF Growth Rate (Years 1-10): 12.0% • Discount Rate (WACC): 9.0% • Terminal Growth Rate: 3.0% 10-YEAR FCF PROJECTION: Year FCF ($M) PV Factor PV of FCF ($M) ------------------------------------------------------------ 1 $7,904,960,000 0.9174 $7,252,256,881 2 $8,853,555,200 0.8417 $7,451,860,281 3 $9,915,981,824 0.7722 $7,656,957,353 4 $11,105,899,643 0.7084 $7,867,699,299 5 $12,438,607,600 0.6499 $8,084,241,481 6 $13,931,240,512 0.5963 $8,306,743,540 7 $15,602,989,373 0.5470 $8,535,369,509 8 $17,475,348,098 0.5019 $8,770,287,936 9 $19,572,389,870 0.4604 $9,011,672,008 10 $21,921,076,654 0.4224 $9,259,699,678 ------------------------------------------------------------ Total PV of 10-Year FCF: $82,196,787,965 TERMINAL VALUE: • Year 11 FCF: $22,578,708,954 • Terminal Value: $376,311,815,902 • PV of Terminal Value: $158,958,177,800 VALUATION SUMMARY: • Enterprise Value: $241.2B • Shares Outstanding: 0.05B • Intrinsic Value per Share: $4756.75 • Current Price: $1988.26 • Upside/Downside: +139.2% • Margin of Safety: 58.2% -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ================================================================================ SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS - Intrinsic Value per Share ================================================================================ How intrinsic value changes with different growth and discount rates: Growth → 3% 5% 8% 10% 12% 15% WACC ↓ ------------------------------------------------------------------ 8% $ 2698↑ $ 3154↑ $ 3987↑ $ 4659↑ $ 5442↑ $ 6861↑ 9% $ 2279 $ 2651↑ $ 3326↑ $ 3870↑ $ 4502↑ $ 5643↑ 10% $ 1973 $ 2282 $ 2844↑ $ 3295↑ $ 3818↑ $ 4760↑ 11% $ 1739↓ $ 2002 $ 2478 $ 2859↑ $ 3299↑ $ 4092↑ 12% $ 1554↓ $ 1781↓ $ 2190 $ 2517 $ 2894↑ $ 3571↑ Current Price: $1988.26 Base FCF: $7,058,000,000M Terminal Growth: 2.5% (constant) Legend: ↑ = 30%+ upside | ↓ = 10%+ downside ================================================================================ ================================================================================ PROBABILITY-WEIGHTED VALUATION ================================================================================ Bear Case (2061.12) × 25% = $515.28 Base Case (3817.58) × 50% = $1908.79 Bull Case (4756.75) × 25% = $1189.19 ======================================== Weighted Average Intrinsic Value: $3613.26 Current Price: $1988.26 Upside/Downside: +81.7% Margin of Safety: 45.0% ================================================================================